Posted on Categories Opinion, Programming, TutorialsTags , Leave a comment on On debugging

On debugging

My favorite advice on debugging is from Professor Norman Matloff:

Finding your bug is a process of confirming the many things that you believe are true – until you find one that is not true.


Continue reading On debugging

Posted on Categories Computer Science, Expository Writing, Programming, TutorialsTags , , , , , , 1 Comment on On indexing operators and composition

On indexing operators and composition

In this article I will discuss array indexing, operators, and composition in depth. If you work through this article you should end up with a very deep understanding of array indexing and the deep interpretation available when we realize indexing is an instance of function composition (or an example of permutation groups or semigroups: some very deep yet accessible pure mathematics).


A permutation of indices

In this article I will be working hard to convince you a very fundamental true statement is in fact true: array indexing is associative; and to simultaneously convince you that you should still consider this amazing (as it is a very strong claim with very many consequences). Array indexing respecting associative transformations should not be a-priori intuitive to the general programmer, as array indexing code is rarely re-factored or transformed, so programmers tend to have little experience with the effect. Consider this article an exercise to build the experience to make this statement a posteriori obvious, and hence something you are more comfortable using and relying on.

R‘s array indexing notation is really powerful, so we will use it for our examples. This is going to be long (because I am trying to slow the exposition down enough to see all the steps and relations) and hard to follow without working examples (say with R), and working through the logic with pencil and a printout (math is not a spectator sport). I can’t keep all the steps in my head without paper, so I don’t really expect readers to keep all the steps in their heads without paper (though I have tried to organize the flow of this article and signal intent often enough to make this readable). Continue reading On indexing operators and composition

Posted on Categories Opinion, Programming, TutorialsTags , , , , 1 Comment on Iteration and closures in R

Iteration and closures in R

I recently read an interesting thread on unexpected behavior in R when creating a list of functions in a loop or iteration. The issue is solved, but I am going to take the liberty to try and re-state and slow down the discussion of the problem (and fix) for clarity.

The issue is: are references or values captured during iteration?

Many users expect values to be captured. Most programming language implementations capture variables or references (leading to strange aliasing issues). It is confusing (especially in R, which pushes so far in the direction of value oriented semantics) and best demonstrated with concrete examples.


Please read on for a some of the history and future of this issue. Continue reading Iteration and closures in R

Posted on Categories Computer ScienceTags , 2 Comments on The magrittr monad

The magrittr monad

Monads are a formal theory of composition where programmers get to invoke some very abstract mathematics (category theory) to argue the minutia of annotating, scheduling, sequencing operations, and side effects. On the positive side the monad axioms are a guarantee that related ways of writing code are in fact substitutable and equivalent; so you want your supplied libraries to obey such axioms to make your life easy. On the negative side, the theory is complicated.

In this article we will consider the latest entry of our mad “programming theory in R series” (see Some programming language theory in R, You don’t need to understand pointers to program using R, Using closures as objects in R, and How and why to return functions in R): category theory!

Continue reading The magrittr monad

Posted on Categories Computer Science, Programming, Public Service Article, TutorialsTags , , , , , 13 Comments on Using closures as objects in R

Using closures as objects in R

For more and more clients we have been using a nice coding pattern taught to us by Garrett Grolemund in his book Hands-On Programming with R: make a function that returns a list of functions. This turns out to be a classic functional programming techique: use closures to implement objects (terminology we will explain).

It is a pattern we strongly recommend, but with one caveat: it can leak references similar to the manner described in here. Once you work out how to stomp out the reference leaks the “function that returns a list of functions” pattern is really strong.

We will discuss this programming pattern and how to use it effectively. Continue reading Using closures as objects in R